Predicting the Implications of the 2026 Midterms
A wave of electoral map changes across the United States has raised questions about the fairness and legitimacy of the midterm congressional elections. How might those redrawn electoral maps impact the outcome of this critical election?
The exact partisan consequences of the current round of redistricting are uncertain. Texas’ efforts, for example, may not yield the planned additional Republican seats because of declining Latino support for Trump. Nonetheless, there is broad consensus that redistricting will increase the number of Republican-leaning seats overall and solidify the Republicans’ structural advantage in the House of Representatives. Black representation in the House is predicted to significantly fall over the next decade. And House districts are expected to be less competitive.
Reduced competitiveness, in turn, will have other downstream impacts on American democracy, such as elevating the importance of the few remaining competitive districts, giving swing voters in those districts disproportionate influence over national policy, and eroding the responsiveness of the House to public opinion. These are the kinds of dynamics that fuel polarization and damage perceptions of the legitimacy of government and democracy, things already under strain in the United States. More broadly, they contribute to democratic backsliding. Political gridlock is also likely to increase, further imperiling government functioning—another significant dent in the United States’ democratic armor.
Other concerns abound. There is the possibility of election deniers using their control of key administrative positions to manipulate voter rolls (for example, Victoria Bishop, a county clerk in Michigan, allegedly cancelled voter registrations); interfere in elections (for example, Rick Jackson, the Republican nominee for governor of Georgia, has likened Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger to Judas for refusing Trump’s request to “find” 11,780 votes in 2020); or refuse to certify results they dislike (Andy Biggs, who voted against certifying the Arizona 2020 presidential election results when he served in the U.S. House, is currently the Republican nominee for governor of Arizona).
The Trump administration’s moves against universities and other social and business actors, including media organizations and law firms, have dark implications for civil and political rights. The staggering amount of secretive “dark money” pouring through the midterm elections, currently estimated at upwards of a record $1 billion, is undermining transparency and giving disproportionate weight to wealthy special interests. Rising political violence and election-related terrorism are additional and obvious potential threats.
Looking beyond the 2026 midterms, the performance of the new maps in the 2026 midterms will shape the appetite for future redistricting in advance of the 2028 and subsequent elections. There is also the Electoral College to consider. Like the partisan nature of the U.S. districting process, the Electoral College is another comparatively unique feature of the United States’ electoral system—one employed by no other peer democracy. Twice in the last 25 years, it has delivered the presidency to the loser of the nation wide popular vote. It has accordingly come in for special scholarly opprobrium for its violation of the majority rule principle and hence of fundamental norms of democratic fairness.
For all of these reasons, the United States’ 2026 midterm elections seem likely to occur under an increasingly authoritarian shadow. Yet hope remains for future elections.
Here are three things the United States needs to safeguard future elections:
- National standards, passed either through congressional legislation or constitutional amendment, that could eliminate, or greatly restrict, partisan gerrymandering. Such standards came very close to passage in 2021 with the Freedom to Vote Act. As Daniel Ziblatt and Steven Levitsky argue in Tyranny of the Minority, uniform and neutral standards could become a reality in the near future —especially if the Democrats regain control of Congress, Trump’s influence within the Republican party weakens, and the anti-majoritarian Senate filibuster is limited. Further, an escalating redistricting war that carries into 2028 and beyond is likely to result in a partisan near-stalemate. In the longer term, redistricting wars might eventually be checked by ground-level swells of voter opposition. More states may simply reject extreme partisan gerrymanders, as Indiana did in late 2025.
- Nonpartisan redistricting commissions deployed in additional states, perhaps coupled with other state-level statutory or constitutional reforms to rein in partisan gerrymandering and increase the nonpartisanship of election administration.
- Reform in the Electoral College. The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, an agreement among participating states to circumvent the counter-majoritarian aspects of the Electoral College by awarding their electoral college votes to the presidential candidate who has won the national popular vote, has been enacted by 19 jurisdictions, which together control 222 of the 270 electoral college votes needed to activate the compact. And it has been taken up in another six states, which together control 61 additional electoral college votes. It is therefore conceivable that in the near future, enough states will ratify the compact to make it a reality, to the great benefit of electoral fairness and democratic legitimacy in the United States.
Democratic backsliding in the United States and globally is an unfortunate reality of the twenty-first century. Contrary to the prediction of Francis Fukuyama that the turn of the century would ‘end history’ through the triumph of liberal democracy, the 2000s have instead ushered in myriad pressures on democracy. Some of the most significant are in the electoral realm, striking at the core of modern, representative democracy.
The United States’ current and unprecedented mid-district redistricting war is both a symptom of this backsliding and a cause of further democratic erosion. But the nonlinearity of democracy’s path contains seeds of hope, as well as of despair. To adapt the words of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., the arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends toward democracy, as the United States’ own history attests—with Reconstruction giving way to Redemption, which in turn gave way to the Second Reconstruction. We must hope that beyond 2026, citizens will push forward both state and federal efforts that will strengthen the United States’ democratic electoral framework, helping to reverse backsliding and reassert democracy’s central place in our national identity.
Heather Stoll is an associate professor in political science at the University of California, Santa Barbara.
Thumbnail credit: Wikimedia Commons
Global Policy At A Glance
Global Policy At A Glance is IGCC’s blog, which brings research from our network of scholars to engaged audiences outside of academia.
Read More