Skip to main content
Trending Topics:
National Security Strategy
Future of AI
Nuclear Arms Control

On Truth and Reconciliation in America

November 16, 2026
Jon Gould

Talking Policy Podcast

Many Americans feel the deck is stacked against them, and that wealthy elites escape accountability by playing by a different set of rules. On this episode of Talking Policy, guest host Stephan Haggard speaks with Jon B. Gould, dean of the School of Social Ecology at UC Irvine and a contributing author to the November 2026 issue of Current History. Gould, a former Justice Department advisor, makes the case for a national truth and reconciliation commission to investigate corruption and abuses of power, and to help rebuild trust in American governmental institutions.

This episode was recorded on October 14, 2026. The conversation has been edited for length and clarity. Subscribe to Talking Policy on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Captivate, or wherever you get your podcasts.

Lindsay: Hi, this is Lindsay Shingler, the host of Talking Policy. I’m proud to share that the November 2026 issue of Current History, the third published under the editorial management of the UC Institute on Global Conflict and Cooperation, is now available. Visit ucpress.edu and search for Current History under “Journals” to read and subscribe.

On this episode of Talking Policy, we’re excited to feature an interview between Steph Haggard, one of IGCC’s research directors and the senior editor of Current History, and Jon Gould, the dean of UC Irvine’s School of Social Ecology, who wrote a featured essay in the November issue titled “On Truth and Reconciliation in America.”

We are so happy to be able to share some of the fresh voices and insights from Current History with you here on Talking Policy. I hope you enjoy the conversation.

Steph: Welcome to Talking Policy podcast. My name is Stephan Haggard. I’m the research director at the [UC] Institute on Global Conflict and Cooperation for Democracy and Global Governance. And we’re really pleased today to be joined by Jon Gould, who’s the dean of the UC Irvine School of Social Ecology. Jon has an incredibly wide-ranging body of work on justice policy, social change, government reform, with a number of books and articles on topics ranging from criminal justice to hate speech to sexual harassment.

But let me just jump right to the bottom line of our conversation. Jon, in this essay you make a sort of bold proposal that the U.S. should move towards the establishment of a truth and reconciliation commission, for example, modeled on the South African example. But you start the essay with this really interesting discussion of a classroom experience you had with some first-generation students at Irvine, and I thought that was an excellent framing for the piece. Can you talk about that conversation? I thought it was quite moving.

Jon: Absolutely. And thank you very much for having me. It’s a delight to have this conversation. So as a dean, I actually teach a class every now and then, and last year I was teaching a class on the future of California. We had about 40 students in the class, and [as] is the case at my school, about half of them are the first in their families to go to college. About a third of the way through the class, I asked the students, “How many of you believe in the promise of the American dream?” Now, these are, as I said, first in their families to go to college. They’re getting an education because we presume they really want to go out and make a difference. Out of a class of 40, only five raised their hands, and I was shocked by that number.

And so this began a conversation with them about why is it you don’t believe in the American dream. And some of it was that housing is so expensive, they don’t think they will be able to afford a house, and that is kind of part of how people envision the American dream. They worry about whether there’s going to be room for them in the workforce. But really, the bigger problem was that they felt like—and this is their words, not mine—that the system is rigged. And I said to them, “What does that mean?” And they said they believe that the powerful get to act with impunity, and they’re never held to account. And from my perspective, this resonated because of some polling that I had seen.

So in February of 2026, Reuters did a poll that found 70% of Americans believe that the powerful are rarely held accountable. To me, this is an extraordinarily dangerous condition for a democracy, because I think people can tolerate political disagreement. They can even sometimes tolerate governmental failure. But it becomes corrosive when they don’t believe that the institutions apply equally to others. And as I talked further with the students, it was clear that they were looking at the Trump administration, but they also were savvy enough to appreciate that the crisis didn’t begin with him, he’s accelerated it. And they also pointed, for example, to the Jeffrey Epstein scandal, because this was where they thought—and I think there’s reason to believe that they’re right here—that the well-connected can escape meaningful scrutiny. It’s almost like the powerful operate under impunity. And we’ve seen, in my view, Trump accelerating this problem with the abuses of executive authority, conflicts of interest, the influence of wealthy donors. And so between Epstein and Trump and others, it really reinforces the perception that the well-connected escape accountability, and that is a fundamental problem of democracy.

When people think the criminal justice system doesn’t work to hold folks accountable, when they think Congress has abandoned meaningful oversight, when they think the Supreme Court has given the president immunity, what are we going to do when we don’t even agree on basic facts and when criminal prosecutions frankly get interpreted as partisan witch hunts? That’s why I am recommending a truth and reconciliation commission, because we need to get past this notion that there’s no punishment for individual wrongdoing.

Steph: There’s just so much to unpack there, Jon. I just want to make one leading observation. And that is that one of the things that you’ve just said that I think is particularly interesting is that democracy isn’t just a matter of formal institutions functioning, but it has a kind of normative underpinning. And I think one of the points that comes out of that story for me is that fairness matters, and if there’s a sense that the system is fair, there’s more likelihood that your democracy will remain robust.

But let me turn to the particular solution you suggest, and just to personalize for a minute, how did you gravitate towards this idea? A lot of your work is on American politics. It’s even on the state of California. But then you pick up this idea of going to a South African example, and I was just curious about the intellectual trajectory there.

Jon: I came of age in the ’80s and ’90s believing very much in the institutions of American democracy. I still believe in the institutions of American democracy. I’m trained as a political scientist. I’m trained as a public policy practitioner. I’m trained as a lawyer. I’ve worked in international human rights before. In fact, I helped train some of the observers for the first all-race elections in South Africa in 1994.

But I believe deeply in something, Steph, that you said before, which is democracies do not operate simply by the institutions working. Democracies operate when the norms in civil society support them, when people really trust in one another, when they trust in the system. Years ago, right after the wall fell in Eastern Europe, I would do talks for visiting groups of judges and lawyers and others from the former Eastern Bloc at the request of the United States Information Agency. And my talk was supposed to be on how American constitutionalism works. And I remember saying something to people then, which I believe even more deeply today, which is the American system does not operate based on its rules. It operates based on its norms. And the example I always gave was what happens if one party controls the presidency and both Houses of Congress, and the president wants to nominate his brother or brother-in-law or some other crony to be the attorney general, and Congress just goes along with it, and that person decides not to follow any of the laws. Would there be any accountability? And I think the answer that we have been seeing is: not so much.

So that’s how I get to this point where this person, myself, who’s believed so deeply in our institutions and want to believe so deeply in our institutions, and who believes absolutely in the promise of America, gets to this point where I say, really, the way back is not through existing institutions, but through something like a truth and reconciliation commission.

Steph: For our listeners, can you give us a little bit more detail on what these truth and reconciliation commissions are? How do they work? What are their objectives? And how did you see the South African example in particular as providing a kind of way forward?

Jon: First of all, we’ve had truth and reconciliation commissions in the United States. One of the most recent ones was in Maryland which had a lynching truth and reconciliation commission. There have also been, I think, 30 local initiatives across the United States. The notion here is rather than focusing on punishment, these commissions try to create accountability, and they do it through conditional amnesty. The idea is to establish a public record of the abuses of power, to identify those who are responsible, and to recommend reforms.

Unlike criminal trials, they’re examining broader institutional failures, not just simply individual guilt. So what they typically do, and South Africa was the best example of this, is they call lots and lots of witnesses to testify about what happened. They have the power to do that typically through subpoena power. Now, this raises the question, why would someone come and testify before them if all they’re going to do is incriminate themselves, and thus be subject to criminal prosecutions? What South Africa did, and what other truth and reconciliation commissions have done, is they offer conditional amnesty, which is to say, “If you come and testify truthfully about what you know and what you were involved in, you get amnesty. You cannot be prosecuted for that.” That is a key piece of this, because what we’re trying to do with a truth and reconciliation commission is to find out what happened, to get that factual record of abuses. Truth is necessary here, and it’s in fact more important than the reform. The reform’s not a substitute for it. If you can’t get the truth, you can’t come up with reform.

Now, South Africa was the most recent largest example of it. It was an imperfect process. They did not get everybody to testify. Not everybody was willing to accept amnesty. But they were able to show what had happened in that country for years and years. I think in the United States, we need something like this because we just don’t have agreement on basic facts of what’s happening, and everything gets fed through this partisan lens of it’s a Democratic witch hunt or it’s a Republican witch hunt. We’re using special prosecutors to criminalize that which should be a political debate. There’s a lot of impunity that’s going on right now. There’s a lot of double-dealing that’s going on right now, and I don’t say that as a partisan. I think once you talk to Republicans off the record, they are willing to acknowledge that as well. But don’t trust them, don’t trust me. Trust the American people in polling who are telling us by huge majorities that they think the system is rigged. So we need to get to the bottom of that. If we can bring a process like this forward, I think we have opportunities to get at what’s happened, and that then puts us in a position to talk about eventually what meaningful reform could look like, what it would involve.

Steph: So Jon, one thing that struck me in reading this is to go back to the origins of these commissions and it seems like the South African commission, you have an example of almost like an historic defeat of an outgoing authoritarian regime with an incredible amount of public support for the new democratic government, which is coming into office. And I’m just wondering what the circumstances would be in the United States that would permit the establishment of such an entity. Because the process of getting to it is clearly going to be a big part of the story. Can you get this thing actually set up? And we saw January 6th, it’s clearly possible to put something like that together. But at that juncture, you had at least some Republicans who were willing to play. What do you think it will take for this to get put in place?

Jon: The first thing is Trump has to be out of office. There is no way that a truth and reconciliation commission goes forward with the sitting president being one of the targets of looking at what’s happened. So we need to get past the presidency of Trump. We also need a broader recognition among elected officials that what we have seen recently is problematic, and that is going to require public opinion continuing to turn against the Trump administration such that Republican office holders are willing to say in public what they say in private, which is that they too are concerned about the lack of oversight of this administration, about the network of donors and others who have influence, and about the self-dealing or the allegations of self-dealing among the president’s family and of folks connected to him. So that’s going to have to happen. And so really it will be at a point where Trump is weakened and where the Republicans are more willing to look at themselves.

It is also going to require a Democratic Party and Democratic leaders who do not come into power bloodthirsty to bludgeon the opposition, to use the power of the state to penalize versus the power of the state to understand what happened. That’s almost asking people, both sides, to go against human nature. And so I am one of the first to recognize and acknowledge that this will be very difficult to have happen. But I think it is absolutely essential if we are going to heal America past not only this last several years, but frankly the last 10 years or so where we are so divided, where we cannot even agree that there are crimes going on or at least bad behavior going on, where people have thought that we are using investigative powers to punish political opponents and not punish wrongdoing. So it is going to take a lot. I am sanguine about the chances here, but we’re not going to get there unless we actually start talking about it, propose it, and see if we can get some more buy-in.

Steph: I’m wondering if this still doesn’t require some sort of postmortem on the part of Republicans or some part of the party turning back towards the center in a way and seeking to disavow some of the excesses of this administration even more than the first. What struck me about the South African case was you did have members of the outgoing regime who made the decision that either for their own personal reasons or in the name of social peace, some kind of process like this was required, and they were willing to participate in it.

Jon: I don’t think you’re wrong, and as I said, it will require Trump to be out of office, and it will require Republicans to be willing to look not only outward, but inward. Now, my suspicion, and we are recording this 19 days before the upcoming midterm elections–actually, 20 days before the upcoming midterm elections. I think most of the money is on the House of Representatives flipping. I think there’s a better than 50% chance that the Senate flips. If that happens, we’re moving in the direction of a Republican Party that will be willing to look at where the excesses have been. If in ’28, Trump is replaced by a Democrat, and I think it will require a Democrat to be in the White House for there to be a truth and reconciliation commission. If that happens, parties typically do postmortems to figure out where did they go wrong, why did they lose? And it will require a Republican Party that thinks one of the reasons that they lost is they lost the thread of what it meant to be a party that believed in the rule of law, and they may then be willing to accept a truth and reconciliation commission.

But this isn’t just Republicans needing to be willing to accept this. It needs to include Democrats who, in addition to doing all of their investigations they want to do over the next two years, will be willing to step back and say, “This is ultimately about trying to figure out what went wrong and to prevent it, not simply to score points and try to set ourselves up to be the winning party at even larger numbers in the future.” That’s almost impossible to accomplish either. What happened in South Africa, and why it was so meaningful and so unusual, is, as you said, people from across the political spectrum—people who had benefited and been the victims of the system before—were willing to join together because they realized if they didn’t, this was just going to spin up more and more violence. I think, here, we’re not at the point where we’re risking spinning up more violence. We are, though, risking spinning up more turmoil, more distrust, and the breakdown of democracy. We talk often in this country about the wisdom of the Founding Fathers, thinking for some reason that they are wholly different than human beings like us. If they can do it, we can do it, and if we don’t do it, we have only ourselves to blame if we watch democracy start to ebb.

Steph: You’re preaching to the converted on my end. But let me go back to some of the features of the process of these commissions, because one of the interesting things you say in the essay has to do with the nature of accountability under such a system. And you underline the fact that this isn’t criminal accountability where the standards are much higher, it’s tougher, there are more personal consequences. It’s a different kind of accountability. Can you unfold that for us? Because that seems quite crucial to the whole project.

Jon: Certainly. So in many ways, what we’re seeing is a breakdown in the rules of how government is supposed to operate, how executive authority is supposed to operate, [and] how legislative oversight is supposed to work. So as I say, this is not about punishment. It’s about truth, understanding, it’s about some form of accountability, at least in public opinion, and then it’s about moving to meaningful kinds of reform. So what does meaningful reform look like? It means increasing the oversight powers of the executive. It means not only exposing the network of donors and officials who can trade access and influence, it means coming up with rules that close those doors. It means changing the rules of how people can trade information they have as officials for economic gain.

We saw a number of reforms post-Watergate. I think those are the kinds of reforms that can come from this kind of a truth and reconciliation process. We may need to be thinking about constitutional amendments, as well, to change the kinds of decisions from the Supreme Court that allow gobs and gobs of money from people who are not individuals to go to elected officials. Those are the kinds of reforms that can come from a process like this, that can not only prevent some of these things from happening in the future, but most importantly, can make people trust again, or at least at higher levels, that the powerful will be held to the same rules as the rest of us, and that we don’t look like a kleptocracy or some other form of non-democratic system.

Steph: I want to turn back to the issue of reform in somewhat more detail in a second. But before we do that, can you reflect on the January 6th commission? Because this struck me as a really interesting exercise. First of all, the thoroughness of the work really did strike me. And on the other hand, it seems to have vanished and so it seems like this accountability question really is a long game where you’re contesting history in a way. You’re trying to pose an alternative history to the one that has held sway.

Jon: The January 6th commission, at least in theory, was supposed to be a truth-seeking investigation. It did not work and it did not work for one of the prerequisites you and I have already talked about [for] a truth and reconciliation commission in the United States, which is that one of the targets, President Trump, potentially the largest target of the commission, was still politically powerful at that time and had absolutely no interest in there being any kind of truthful accounting. And because he had no interest in that, and because he was politically powerful, and because so many Republican legislators were scared to challenge him, we didn’t have the prerequisites for the kind of investigation that would get at truth. So this kind of process, again, works only when the targets are not able to successfully challenge them.

Now, I think one of the objections to what I am proposing is that Trump will have power to prevent this because he has the pardon power, and that he will then be able to pardon lots and lots of people, and they will then have no reason to go testify before a commission that has subpoena power because nothing can happen if they say no. And that is absolutely one of the potential problems. What I would say is he can’t pardon everybody, and it may be the second level or the tertiary level of people who’ve been involved in some of these ill dealings that will be called before the committee and will be willing to testify because they’ll be given amnesty. That at least will get the stories out there. Will they get contested by those who challenge them? Absolutely. Might that end in a January 6th sort of reaction? Potentially, but I’m not prepared to declare defeat now before we’ve even tried something like that. Moreover, there are state mechanisms that could be used to accomplish the same thing that don’t allow a president to use the pardon power to stop people from testifying.

Steph: You mentioned the pardon power, and I don’t know if you’re familiar with this book by Bob Bauer and Jack Goldsmith, After Trump, but it’s a really interesting book on how to approach the reform of the executive. And the pardon power is really interesting here for two reasons. First of all, it affects your ability to do this kind of thing, because of course if people can just get immunity, then there’s no reason for them to subject themselves to the process. But also, it strikes me as an example of something that needs to be reformed. So if you were God of the universe, as my colleague Lindsay Shingler says, what would be the top three or four areas of real institutional reform that you think a process like this might tackle?

Jon: So you’ve already mentioned one of the top reforms, which is some limit on the pardon power. If the president can just hand these out to everybody, it really defeats any kind of accountability after the fact. I think the challenge is this administration probably cannot figure out absolutely everybody that it would want to give the pardons to or ought to give the pardons to if it really wants to shut down any kind of accountability. But that would be number one. While the president should have the pardon power, there need to be some limits on it so that it is used consistent with the rule of law.

Number two, there have to be greater restrictions on the ability of elected officials to increase their personal gain while they are in office. We are seeing this with the president’s family. There’s evidence of Hunter Biden having done similar things, trading on his father’s presidency. We’re seeing this with members of Congress. Heck, there are arguments that members of the Supreme Court have done that. That’s got to be another one.

I think also we need serious campaign finance reform, and I think we need to be looking at even more lobbying reform. But to me, one of the biggest issues, and I don’t have an easy answer on this one, and this is why I think the truth and reconciliation process could be really good at coming up with other ideas, is how do you hold an executive branch and a president accountable, especially given the Supreme Court’s decision giving the president really greater sway to avoid criminal prosecution after he’s been in office. What do you do to encourage a president’s party or any members of Congress to hold the executive branch accountable? I don’t have a great answer on that, but that does strike me as one of the great weaknesses in our constitutional system right now, and that has to be something that we address.

Steph: Let’s drill down in these last few minutes on two of the substantive proposals you’ve vetted. And here I think your knowledge as a lawyer and a constitutional scholar will help some of our listeners who might not know how to think about this. You have a Supreme Court ruling now in Citizens United. So what is it that a legislature can do in the face of that ruling to at least round the edges of that or perhaps walk back some of the some of the implications of that ruling? Which I interpret as basically giving corporations carte blanche to be represented as citizens via money and therefore taking caps off what firms as well as rich individuals can give. Is there some way that the legislative process could address that particular problem? Because it seems to be one that really is part of the corruption.

Jon: Yeah, that is a biggie. And the easy answer is to say we need a constitutional amendment to deal with that. I have a hard time seeing that getting through state legislatures. There are ways under corporate law where we could change the conditions that entities have to go through to become incorporated. I think we could encourage shareholder suits as well about whether the company is wasting shareholder money in some of the political activity that it is doing, spending on behalf of the entity. But Citizens United is a biggie. That is a way that we see corporate interests, non-individuals having a strong influence on who becomes our elected officials.

How do you get to the point where anyone would want to come up with a constitutional amendment to change Citizens United? They have to appreciate what’s been going on and the way that there is a back-scratching relationship between lobbyists and legislators. How do you uncover that? Through a truth and reconciliation process, where we’re not saying, “Hey, we’re going to be sending you on to criminal prosecution, referring you to the Justice Department or somewhere else,” but instead saying, “We want you to tell the story of how it happens and how it works.” Because my suspicion is when Americans hear about how this happens and how it works, they will be appalled. That’s the kind of thing that may lead to a kind of groundswell where legislators feel like maybe we do have to pass a constitutional amendment.

Steph: Jon, this circles all the way back to that conversation you had with students in your class, because the way I interpreted that was that the students, in essence, were preoccupied with the problem of corruption. And not only corruption in the contemporary sense of taking a bribe, but in that old republican almost virtue sense of the individual’s private interest taking precedence over the public good, the interests of the nation. Do you have any closing thoughts on how a truth and reconciliation commission might address the issue of corruption? In cases like South Africa, they were dealing with systemic violence and racism. Those are issues in the United States. They are issues everywhere. But corruption seems to have risen to the top of the agenda quite surprisingly to me in this election, and I wonder if some of your thoughts on how to reform the system with respect to corruption, you might vet those briefly.

Jon: I think the students were reacting to the sense that all of this corruption over here is preventing them ultimately from getting their own shot at the American dream, their own chance. Because it’s an insider’s game over here. Certain people get the chance, and others don’t. It’s not surprising to me to see that arise right now at a time where people are feeling economically challenged. It doesn’t take any one of us to tell people that gas prices are up, that inflation is up, that they feel that AI is potentially coming for their futures and for their current jobs. People are feeling on edge economically. So when people are feeling on edge economically, they’re looking for answers about why that is, and there are lots of large geopolitical reasons for this, including whether AI is going to be regulated or not; is someone going to stop the war in the Middle East?

But there’s almost an easier story to tell about these insiders who get the goodies and you don’t. And when you have a president’s family that seems to be benefiting substantially, when you have some candidates running for office who are being portrayed as having made millions while being public officials—I’m thinking of Ken Paxton in Texas, this is the strong attack against him there—it becomes a really easy story for people to understand about why they’re not being given opportunity, why power is being concentrated. When they look at billionaires spending billions on campaigns, or at least millions, they wonder, “Why are they doing that? What is it that they’re trying to get out of that I’m not going to get out of it?” And I will say billionaires poll horribly among younger Americans. So it’s all part of that same notion that these students want their fair shot at being able to get ahead. They’re not asking someone to hand it to them. They’re willing to work for it, but they want a fair shot at it. And to the extent that they believe that the system doesn’t allow them that fair shot because there are insiders who are spending their money to hold onto their goodies.

It’s not just a convenient story that can be told. I think it’s a reality, and it is a reality that if we do not address, we are going to lose the faith of the next generation of Americans. We’re losing the faith right now of the current generation of Americans, and that, to me, is the largest risk to the success of this democratic experiment that’s only 250 years old right now. I think we all want to see it succeed. Those of us who are in a position to try to help it move forward have an obligation to do that. I think a truth and reconciliation commission is a strong start. Is it the only way? No. Is it likely to succeed? We’ll find out, but the only way we find out is if we try it, and I’m hoping that’s something we will see going forward.

Steph: My guest is Jon Gould. He’s the Dean of the School of Social Ecology [at UC] Irvine. I just had a wonderful time talking to you about these topics, and the name of the essay is “On Truth and Reconciliation in America”. It’s forthcoming in Current History. And Jon, it was a pleasure talking to you, and I hope we can get you back on Talking Policy in the future.

Jon: What a pleasure to talk to you, I really enjoyed it.  I hope people will read the article. I’m sure I’ll hear from folks whether they agree with it or not. But I appreciate the opportunity.

/